The Very Honourable Student
That night James arrived at the Professor’s house wearing his best suit, Armani tie, polished shoes, and a clean-cut shave. It was 7:00pm. Not a minute early - he didn’t want to be rude, and heaven forbid, not a minute late. He knocked on the brass handle, but not too hard, “dock dock”. Maybe he knocked too softly. Maybe they couldn’t hear. Maybe he should knock again?
“You must be James,” said a woman with a rather gruff voice, opening the door.
She was plump with bushy eyebrows and a very large crooked nose which was even more obvious from profile. She wore a white apron over an undersized black and white checkered dress that made her flesh bulge in all the wrong places.
“Yes I’m James.”The maid took a few moments to size him up and down from head to toe. “Come with me,” she said.
James followed the maid down a long corridor. He noticed the jade green Oriental rug beneath him with its intricate patterns of ancient coins. At the end of the corridor, they arrived at a seating room.
“Wait here,” she said, pointing her fat finger at the floor. “The Professor and Mrs. Wood will be down shortly. In the meantime, what do you drink? Wine? Whisky? Brandy?”
“Brandy please.”
The maid left the room and James felt a sudden sense of relief. There was something about her that made him feel very uncomfortable.
James sat on a large, dark brown leather couch and took note of his surrounds. There were paintings of Oriental women with flowers, bronze statues of figures wrapped in contorted positions, and various decorative vases of expensive aesthetic. The marvelous stained glass windows at the back reflected brilliant colours and brought to James’s attention framed maps, kaleidoscopes perched on side tables, stacks of Christie’s catalogues next to art and architecture books, Chinese antique furniture, the Professor’s book titled “Ethics for Adversaries” which had been the best selling ethics book in the world for four consecutive years, and a glass bowl with two gold fish.
As James walked around the room, he came across a wall hanging all the awards the Professor had won. There were at least 15 framed including the Miravax Ethics award, the Wainright Ethics Award and the Ruben Award. James was very impressed. He knew the Professor was well accomplished but never knew exactly to what extent. He began to bite his nails furiously. This was a very prestigious dinner. The Professor had hosted this event annually for his top performing ethics student at Princeton University ever since he had began teaching at Princeton ten years ago. It was a very “honorable dinner,” the Professor would say, “for a very honorable student”.
Beneath the Professors awards hung framed photos of his family. There were photos of Mrs. Wood, the Professor himself, and their two children Lucy and Joshua. Joshua was twenty-seven and was now married and living with his wife in Boston where he worked for a consulting firm. And Lucy was also at Princeton but was still living at home with her parents. As James observed the photos he paid particular attention to Lucy, intrigued by her as a baby, a child and a teenager. He found himself touching the glass of her most recent photos, sliding his index finger gently over her face.
For the last two years James had observed Lucy from afar and had developed a heavy attraction to her. Every Tuesday and Thursday, Lucy would wait in the hallway outside the lecture room for her father and they would walk home together.
As time went on, James could not help but develop a rather intense infatuation. He would slip out the back door of the lecture theatre a few minutes before the end of class and then sneak into the hallway as quietly as possible. He would stand at the end of the hallway pretending to read the announcements posted on the corkboard but he would position himself so that he could observe Lucy from the corner of his eye.
James saw that Lucy wore basic clothes that hid her feminine curves, glasses that seemed to cover her face, and her hair in a loosely tied bun that sat just above her shoulders. She always waited alone, never conversing with other students. She played with her hair, spinning the loose strands around her index figure, while engrossed in a textbook.
As James stood fixated with the photos of Lucy hanging in front of him, his heart rate began to beat faster. Despite Lucy’s reserved appearance, it was no question that she was a stunning woman. Underneath her glasses, her textbooks and her baggy clothing, was a soft heart-shaped face with rosy cheeks that rested on high cheekbones, hazel colored almond shaped eyes, long chestnut colored hair, and a slender figure with womanly curves. She was a hidden beauty, oblivious to the powerful effects she had on James.
And so when James received a phone call from the Professor three weeks prior asking him to join his family for dinner, James was over the moon for two reasons rather than one.
“James!” said the Professor, walking into the room with Mrs. Wood. “Mighty wonderful to have you.”James rose to shake the Professor’s hand.“James, this is my lovely wife, Sue.”“Hi Mrs. Wood, very nice to meet you.”
“You too James.”
“Ah, I see you are drinking brandy,” said the Professor. “A very strong drink for a very strong man,” he chuckled.
The Professor was a remarkable individual. Everyone who knew him admired him. He was a magnificent lecturer who spoke with strong enthusiasm and vitality and his ideas resonated and inspired. He never used notes but spoke from memory and wisdom. Even people who didn’t know who the Professor was felt his importance and respected him. For the Professor’s wisdom penetrated from his very physicality. His posture was always upright and his gait steady and considered. His hair was a whitish yellow, like stained snow, and he had a round jovial face with a bulbous nose that seemed the perfect shape to hold his thin silver rimmed spectacles. He wore tweed jackets with leather elbow patches and even ties patterned with varieties of Princeton emblems. Tonight was no exception.
“You must be hungry James,” said Mrs. Wood. “How about we head to the dining room for some dinner?” “Yes, that sounds fantastic Mrs. Wood.”
The moment they entered the dining room, James could see that the table was laid for a feast. The yellow tulips, the tall candles, the shining silver, the lace placemats, and above all, the strong smell of roasting meat from the kitchen which brought an angry growl to James’s stomach. Yet, James noticed that the table was only set for three. “Professor is your daughter not joining us tonight?” he asked. “Not for dinner I’m afraid,” said the Professor. “Lucy is at the library collecting some books, but she should be back in time for desert.”
James gave a quick nod, trying to hide his disappointment.
The meal began with a plate of proscuitto and cantaloupe, and a fresh mango salad. This was followed by the mains: roast chicken, grilled ocean trout, succulent double roasted duck, and a variety of steam vegetables. The Professor had really spoiled him. As they feasted on the sumptuous meal, the Professor insisted that James tell his wife about his focus of study.
A bit shy to talk about his work, James hesitated and then began. “Well I absolutely love the virtue ethics of Plato and Aristotle,” James said.“ My writing focuses on motives and moral character. I look at the virtue of honesty in particular.” He said, pausing often between his words.
“What is it about honesty that interests you?” Mrs. Wood responded, leaning in to listen.
“Well, an honest person must not be identified as merely someone who, for example, practices honest actions and does not cheat.” James said. “If actions are done because the person thinks that honesty is the best policy, or because they fear being caught out, rather than feeling that to do otherwise would be dishonest, they do not portray the actions of an honest person. So to be an honest person really comes down to the intention.”
“Yes because most people instinctually obey fear,” said the Professor. “They avoid behaviour because of penalties, not shame. And because they live by their
feelings and emotions, they pursue pleasures and avoid pains and don’t have an idea of what is good and truly pleasant.”
“Yes, that is exactly right Professor,” said James. “But you see James, to argue such a point is to believe that a person has a final purpose,” said the Professor. “It is to believe that there is a purpose and meaning to life and hence there is a soul that can be perfected. Whilst for much of human history this assumption was easy to make because most people believed that God existed and that God created a purposeful life with deeper meaning, the twentieth century was predominately secular and human progress was less associated with the notion of God.” “Professor, you are right. But how depressing to have a non-teleological view of the world.” “I would have to agree with you James.” The Professor gave James a firm pat on the shoulder and then turned to Mrs.
Wood saying, “James’s writing on the subject is remarkably insightful. You really should read it Sue. James here is one brilliant young man.”
“Thank you Professor. You are too kind.”
When they had finished eating, Lucy had still not returned from the library. The maid came into the room to clear the dishes and noticed that James had finished his brandy. “Would you like some more brandy,” she asked.
“Yes please, thank you very much,” James said while the maid refilled his glass.
“Now how about we move outside to the courtyard and enjoy the evening autumn air,” said the Professor. “We can wait for Lucy to come home before we have desert.” “Yes indeed,” said James. “But do you mind if I use the toilet and make a quick phone call first? You two go ahead, I’ll meet you out there.” “Certainly. The bathroom is on this floor, straight through the corridor to your right,” said the Professor.
Shortly after James rejoined the Professor and his wife, they heard the sound of keys jingling in the door lock. It was Lucy. Lucy entered the room looking a bit messy and flustered. She was carrying a bag full of books on one shoulder, causing a slight slump in her posture.
“Sorry I’m late,” she said to her father while straightening her shirt and fixing her hair self-consciously, realising that there was company in the house. “I couldn’t find the book I was looking for and I searched the shelves for half an hour,” she continued in a voice that was almost inaudible.
“Lucy, I want you to meet James, my student of the year.”
“Hi James”, she said glancing up at him, but then quickly turning her head away. ”Hi Lucy” he said, wiping his sweaty palm against his trousers as inconspicuously as possible before shaking her hand.
“Lucy, you missed out on hearing about James’s brilliant writing on honesty and what it means to be an honest person,” said the Professor, making James blush. ”Oh no! You really didn’t,” James said. Disregarding his comment the professor went on. ”James is a very talented student, the most talented ethics student in the whole country,” he bragged.
As they sat down to eat a delicious strawberry cheesecake, James realised how quiet Lucy was. She barely spoke, but just sat politely, nodding and smiling from time to time. “So Lucy, your father tells me you are an art history student?” said James, trying to spark conversation.
“Yes”, she said.
“That’s great.” “Are you interested in art history at all?” ”Oh yes,” he said, nodding. “What a great subject to study. I am actually a huge fan of French art. Do you know much about it?”
Lucy’s eyes grew wider and her eyebrows rose to form high arches. “Oh yes, I love French art!” she replied. “It’s actually my focus of study.” “Is that so?! Well, perhaps you know a bit about the Rococo period then. It’s my favourite artistic period,” said James.
“Well isn’t that a wonderful coincidence,” said Mrs. Wood. “That’s Lucy’s favourite period too!”
The Professor and Mrs. Wood had been listening to the two and turned to each other, exchanging a wink and a smile.
“So what is your favourite Rococo artist?” asked Lucy, much more interested now. James paused for a minute to think about this one. He moved his lips from side to side, nodded his head slightly back and forth and looked to the left side of the ceiling. “I would have to say Francios Boucher.”
Lucy didn’t say a word but let James continue. She was completely swept away. She found him witty, charming and so pleasantly surprising. She noticed his beautiful blue eyes, his curly brown hair that sat so perfectly around his face and his thin but wide smile. When she caught her behavior, she stopped and focused on what he was saying.
“I just love how idyllic and tranquil his paintings are,” James said while fiddling with his right pocket. He seemed to be trying to push something deep into his pocket. “And there is that sense of eroticism and passion.”
Lucy watched his lips as he spoke. She observed how they were so gentle, how the tip of his tongue tapped the roof of his mouth, how he licked his lips so slightly between pauses.
“And don’t you just love the symbolism and mythology in his paintings?”
“Yes,” replied Lucy, suddenly shaken back to reality. “You won’t believe this, but Boucher is actually my favourite artist,” Lucy squealed.
“Really?” James replied, his mouth opening wide to a gape.
“Yes yes!”
“Which painting of Boucher’s is your favourite?” James asked.
“I would to say Diana at her Bath. But I also love his painting of Luisa O’ Murphy,” she said. “What about you?” “Ah yes, the painting of Luisa is so beautiful. He makes her look so royal in all that velvet material. And her fleshy body is just so erotic, especially with the light which focuses your attention to her bottom!”
Lucy was nodding profusely with agreement. She was suddenly a different person, as if all this time there was this energetic and passionate person hiding underneath all those layers, waiting for the right moment to jump out.
“Lucy, you should take James to see your studio,” said the Professor, politely interrupting the conversation. “Yes, I would really like that,” said James.
Lucy smiled with rosy cheeks but didn’t say anything. “C’mon Lucy,” said Mrs. Wood. “Don’t be shy, your work is really good and James sounds like he can really appreciate a good piece of art.”
At that moment, the maid came to the dining table. She approached James and stood over him, tall, silent and imposing. There was something very peculiar about
her presence. Perhaps it was that twitch in her right eyelid, or that snarl in her nostril. “James, would you like your brandy?” she said, handing him over his glass still half full.
“Oh,” he said, tilting his head to one side. “You left your glass upstairs on the third floor.” “Oh? That must not be mine then.”
“Yes it is your glass.”
“No no, it is no mine,” James replied hastily, bright red in the face. “Yes it is yours. You were the only one drinking brandy.”
Lucy, the Professor, and Mrs. Wood all looked up from their plates. “I found it upstairs, in Lucy’s room, on the table underneath the poster of Boucher’s Luisa O’ Murphy. You must have left it there when you went upstairs by yourself to make the phone call after dinner.” Lucy’s happy face almost instantaneously transformed into a look of horror as she registered the situation.
The Professor and his wife stopped eating at once, their mouths opened wide, still full of cheesecake.
“Please excuse me,” James said, rising from his chair in a hurry.
But as he stood up to leave, a curious object fell from his right pocket. It was small, white, and some sort of fabric with a bit of lace.
“Ah!” gasped Lucy. Just then the Professor’s silver fork dropped from his hand, landing on his plate with a loud clang.